Other formats

    Adobe Portable Document Format file (facsimile images)   TEI XML file   ePub eBook file  

Connect

    mail icontwitter iconBlogspot iconrss icon

Salient. Victoria University Student Newspaper. Volume 33 No. 4. 7 April 1970

[subsection]

"I haven't heard a good new opera or a good new symphony for—eighteen months." Thus Kit Lambert the pop impresario in Tony Palmer's television film All my Loving, making, one would think, no outrageous claim, that is if one allows that he has not heard of Harrison Birtwistle and Cornelius Cardew. But one must realise that Lambert's view is the basis of a total dismissal of modern 'classical' music; for him pop is new heir to the classical tradition. A like view is held by Mr Palmer, who on the strength of a moderately successful film (success of course was inherent in its subject-matter) and of some pretentious writing in the Observer, has been endowed with a certain 'authority'. For him, the Pink Floyd outdo Cardew and Stockhausen in 'modernity', and even the Who's Magic Bus (an inferior reworking of their brilliant 'Talking about my generation') puts Stravinsky's Symphony in Three Movements in the shade.

I shall not waste space on these comparisons, but mention them as an illustration of how the pop world can be blinded to what lies outside it. Lambert and Palmer are the victims of their own high-power distribution techniques whereby nothing gets through without a hard sell. The commercial basis of pop has two important consequences in this context. First, the common ground which exists between genuine musicians in the pop and 'straight' fields is being obscured to the detriment of everyone by promotional smokescreens. Secondly the pop field has become so vast that no common factor apart from commercialism can yet be discerned. All generalisations about pop which I have read have been so exclusive as to be worthless. We must not forget that pop ranges (alas) from Engelbert Humperdinck to the Fugs, from the Monkees to the Beatles, from Pctula Clark to Jimi Hendrix. Not even the presence of a constant beat or of a key is common to all these any longer. As for cxtramusical interpretations, we are still too far inside pop to say anything worthwhile. "Pop music is big enough as a phenomenon to cry out for efforts at sociological explanation", writes Tom Nairn. This very size precludes any success in such efforts. In these notes I shall therefore stress the diversity of pop and the degree to which aspects of its teeming domain correspond to those of 'straight' music today, in the modest hope of creating even a spark of mutual respect and understanding.