Other formats

    Adobe Portable Document Format file (facsimile images)   TEI XML file   ePub eBook file  

Connect

    mail icontwitter iconBlogspot iconrss icon

The Spike or Victoria College Review, October 1903

Debating Society — Urquent Rustice Sane

page 13

Debating Society

Urquent Rustice Sane.

"Hic stupet attonitua rostris; hunc plausus hiantem
Per cuneos—geminatus enim plebisque patrumque—
Corripuit"

Vergil.

Sketch of scholar shouting

Some Debating Societies languish for want of speakers. The Victoria College Debating Society has to cut off its budding orators by "ten o'clock closing ". The younger members of the Society have been specially prominent this year, and a great deal of interest has been shown in the Society by the general public who are always welcome at the meetings. The attendances have been good, though, as usual, thoughts of examinations have reduced the numbers towards the end of the term.

* * * *

The Society uses every effort to adhere to the Syllabus. This year, however, several postponements were necessitated and the Committee resorted to the expedient of holding debates in the short Vacation. This was not a success and one or two of the most interesting subjects were debated with a bare quorum. In spite, however, of postponements, counter attractions and delays, proceedings have never flagged and the Society continues to flourish.

* * * *

It is to be regretted that the Prize Essay Competition fell through. This should be one of the most important events of the year and has in the past resulted in a great deal of interest. The Committee, however, should be careful to choose a subject which the average mind could make a sporting shot at. "Student Types" is more suggestive of artistic than literary enterprise (See our illustration Student Types, No. 1.)

* * * *

The President's Address, which is always one of the most entertaining events of the Session, was delivered this year by page 14 Professor Von Zedlitz. His subject, was "Counters of Thought" or "Lexicographical Anthology"—mysterious expressions which he explained as "words" — "words in the relation of their meanings to human life". Professor Von Zedlitz showed "how the general progress of courtesy and refinement of manners is reflected in language" and in a spirit of quaint humour explained the paradoxes of his theories. This was explained by reference to many examples which joined harmoniously in the serio—comic strain. The "degeneration" and "regeneration" of words were appropriately illustrated by such words as "gamble", "hector" "stout" and "ostler."

How's this?

Words in common speech, I ween,
Share the fate of Kings and crowns
And,—like all things human—know
Their ups and downs.

Stout in ancient times they say
Told of joy at trumpet sound;
When not a beverage, now describes
Distance round.
Exceptions may be counted out—
As when we speak of "good old Stout."

Beer a long long time ago
In terms of pureness could lie stated
Now the common verdict is—
Adulterated
Exceptions should be noted here
As when we speak of "Whiskey Beere."

When little lambs frisked on the hill
Or frolicked blythely to the shamble,
Their action yon could rightly call
A harmless "gamble"
But in these days of "sweeps "you see,
A Gamble cannot guileless be.

An Ostler was in good old days
A Corpulent and jolly host
But later was a servant kept—
For horses most.
Though obsolete about the Court
There's one survival—great at sport.

Words in common speech, I ween,
Know their ups and downs alike
No better instance could be given
Than the "Spike."

The lecturer concluded with a strong appeal to those who would see English the great world-language to prseerve and cherish the immortal glories of the language of Shakspere.

page 15

A College "bard" sends us a "poem" dedicated to the President, Victoria College Debating Society.

As Spring's bright sunshine moves the birds
To fill dark woods with sweet sensation,
So thou mak'st luminous dark words
Of Sweet's narration.

Thine eye perceives in flowers' decay,
(For thine is deepest penetration)
To-morrow's glory—and in slang to-day,
Regeneration.

Oh, may thy genial spirit flood my rhymes,
Impart a joy to all creation,
Preserving still our Shakspere from the time's
Degeneration.

The Debates.

On the first Saturday in the Vacation, H. H. Ostler seconded by G. Toogood, moved "That no event in the History of our Colony has had a more injurious effect upon the morale of its people than the dispatching of Contingents to South Africa" T. Seddon and A J. Thompson opposed. The imperialistic tide set against the movers—and though they made a good fight they were outvoted by a large majority.

The debate with 1 lie Socialist party was the only outside debate of the Session. II. H. Ostler, G. Toogood, A. G. Quartley, A. H. Johnstone and G. F. Dixon represented the College and Messrs Hogg, Fowls, Fagle, Hamilton and Kraig appeared for the Socialists. College opposed the motion "That Collectivism would do away with the present dispute between Capital and Labour." Mr. Hogg's speech in reply was the best of the evening, and the movers were declared victors by one point. The contest was Greatly enjoyed by both sides. The Rev. W. A. Evans and Messrs A. R. Atkinson and R. McNab M.H.R. very kindly acted as judges.

A very lively debate took place on A. G. Tudhope's motion "That the promiscuous reading of magazines is having a baneful influence on the literary taste of the day." This was seconded by G. F. Dixon and opposed by C. Collins and F. P. Kelly. The motion was carried.

The proposition "That to the Individual rather than the Nation the advance of the Empire is due "was propounded by A. G Quartley and with him G. Toogood. F. P. Kelly and F. A. de la Mare opposed, and a well contested debate resulted in a victory for the movers.

The "Parliamentary" debate was a "night out" for the Society. H. P. Richmond was elected Speaker and Miss E. M.

page 16

B. Lynch was appointed Clerk of the House—"with power to speak." The King summond! G. Toogood to form a ministry and Cr. F. Dixon received the portfolio of Fisheries whilst. C. Collins became Minister of Finance. K. Kircaldie was Leader of the Opposition and A. G. Quartley and A. G. Tudhope acted as Opposition Whips. The Premier introduced the Referendum Bill and carried the second reading by one vote. Points of order and abusive language made the atmosphere almost as lurid as it is "in another place"—and the Chairman's rulings which are not "recorded as precedents" tended in the direction of expediting business.

The question of "Cremation"—described as a "burning" one by Miss Lynch who seconded G. F. Dixon in support, ended in a "fiery" discussion across comparatively empty benches. R. Mason and C. H. Taylor opposed. Both sides went into somewhat harrowing details. The supporters of Cremation carried the day.

Graphic border